Teacher's Guide: Counting on Grace
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Recommended for Grades 3-7
It’s Vermont in 1910 and second-best reader
12-year-old Grace is forced to leave school to
work as a doffer in the mill where her mother
works. This fictional tale was inspired by
Lewis W. Hine’s revolutionary photographs of
real 20th-century mill workers.
Grace Forcier and her friend, Arthur Trottier, are the very best students in Miss Lesley’s one room school. Unlike most students in their small Vermont mill town, they aspire to be more than laborers. However, times are tough for both families, and Grace and Arthur seemed doomed to a life of doffing and spinning. Their inspired teacher is determined to help the children and encourages Grace and Arthur to write a letter to the National Child Labor Committee, exposing the poor working conditions and the violations of child labor laws. As a response, the committee sends the photographer and reformer Lewis W. Hine. His passion for changing lives offers the children a bit of hope and offers the nation a glimpse of life in the mills. Neither will be the same again.
Courage • Fear • Family
Community • Hope
Loneliness • Sense of Self
ABOUT THIS AUTHOR
Elizabeth Winthrop has written more than
50 books for readers of all ages, including her
award-winning classic The Castle in the Attic and
its sequel, The Battle for the Castle. Her popular
picture books include Dumpy La Rue, Dog Show,
and Shoes. She lives in New York City for half the
year, and the remaining months in northwestern
Massachusetts, two miles from the small Vermont
mill town where Counting on Grace is set. Visit the
author’s Web site at www.elizabethwinthrop.com
for more information.
Pre- Reading Activity
The National Child Labor Committee was formed in 1904. Ask students to use books in the library or sites on the Internet to investigate the working and social conditions that led to growing awareness of child labor. Visit the Child Labor Public Education Project at
www.continuetolearn.uiowa.edu/laborctr/child_labor/about/us_history.html for helpful information. Instruct them to create a list of the types of employment that exploited children in the 1800s and 1900s.
DISCUSSION AND WRITING
Thematic Connections & Questions for Group Discussion
Courage—Miss Lesley tells Grace and Arthur that it takes time to change minds. How does Miss Lesley show courage in her efforts to change minds about child labor? Discuss how it takes courage to become an activist and make a difference in society. Debate whether Arthur shows courage or cowardice when he purposely injures himself at the mill. What is Grace’s most courageous moment? Who is the least courageous character in the novel?
Fear—What are the mill workers’ greatest fears? Arthur never seems to fear Miss Lesley, but Grace is the victim of her wrath many times. At what point does Grace realize that it isn’t Miss Lesley, but a life as a mill worker that she fears? How does fear cause Mrs. Forcier to tear up the picture that Mr. Hine gives Grace? What does Grace fear most about losing Arthur? How does she cope with
Family—Describe Grace’s family. How is Grace different from Delia? Why is Grace especially vulnerable to her mother’s cruel ways Explain why Grace feels that her grandfather is the only one who understands her. Discuss why Grace makes the statement, “Suddenly I don’t like the family God gave me.” (p. 195)
Community—Despite their poor living and working conditions, the mill workers demonstrate a strong sense of community. How is this especially true when Grace offers to help Mrs. Trottier with her grocery bill? How does Grace’s father encourage her to use her counting skills to help others in the community?
Hope—Why do the mill workers feel hopeless? Why does Mrs. Forcier want Grace to feel that working in the mill should be the best she should hope for? Papa, on the other hand, tells Grace’s mother, “You didn’t settle down and accept the farm. You wanted a better life. She could too.” (p. 106) What causes Mrs. Forcier to change her mind about Grace’s hope to continue her education? How is Mr. Hine a sign of hope for Grace, Arthur, and all the mill rats?
Loneliness—There are many times when Grace is lonely, but there is one particular point in the novel when she feels most alone. Describe this scene. How does her father help her overcome her loneliness? Discuss how her grandfather’s death contributes to her loneliness. What does Arthur do to help?
Sense of Self—Grace says, “Maybe I don’t want to be like Delia. Maybe I want to be somebody else.” (p. 102) Discuss why it is so difficult for Grace to be someone different in her environment. Talk about Grace’s journey toward finding her sense of self. Who helps her along the way?
Language Arts—Arthur is reading The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane. Ask students to write a short paper that draws a parallel between the young soldier and Grace and Arthur’s plight to escape the mill and continue their education. Mr. Hine leaves a notebook for Grace and Arthur, and asks them to write a description of their lives. Ask the girls to write in Grace’s voice, and the boys in Arthur’s voice. Have students share their writing in class. How are the descriptions different? What factors contribute to the differences? Discuss how their lives are similar.
Social Studies—Ask students to research the current child labor laws in the United States (see the Child Labor Coalition’s site at
www.stopchildlabor.org/USchildlabor/fact1.htm). There are 17 prohibited jobs for youth under the age of 18. Have students select one of these jobs and find out why it is on the prohibited list. Most states have child labor laws. Find out if your state has such laws. How are they different from the federal laws?
Science—Have students write an essay that explains the environmental connection to Grace’s statement, “The mill needs the river, but the river don’t need the mill.” (p. 13) There are still environmental issues related to factories and mills in the United States. Find out
what government agency oversees environmental laws. What are the penalties for the violation of such laws?
Music—Read the lyrics to the following mill worker songs: “Hard Times Cotton Mill Girls” and “Poverty
Knock” (www.nhhistory.org/edu/support/nhwork/millsongs.pdf). Then write the lyrics to a song that Grace or Arthur might write. Locate appropriate tunes for the lyrics. Encourage students to individually, or in groups, perform their songs.
Art—Ask students to make a poster that might have been used in the early 1900s to make the public aware of child labor violations. This might be done in cartoon style, or a collage of Lewis W. Hine’s photographs found on the Internet.
Ask students to locate words or terms that are
specifically related to millwork. Have them make an
illustrated dictionary for child workers. Such words
may include: second hand (p. 4), mill rats (p. 4),
doff (p. 5), overseer (p. 6), loom fixer (p. 30),
spinning room (p. 30), balers (p. 31), carding room
(p. 31), and drawing frames (p.31).
A Jane Addams Honor Book for Older Children
An ALA Notable Children’s Book
A Vermont Reads Selection
A Massachusetts Honor Book for Children’s Literature
An IRA-CBC Children’s Choice
An IRA Notable Book for a Global Society
A Dorothy Canfield Fisher Children’s Book Award Nominee
An NCSS-CBC Notable Social Studies Trade Book
for Young People
“History and fiction are woven seamlessly together in
this beautifully written novel.”
—School Library Journal, Starred
BEYOND THE BOOK
The History Place
Sixty photographs by Lewis W. Hine document child labor
in the United States 1908–1912
Resources for teaching about child labor
The National Archives
Ideas for teaching about child labor using Lewis W. Hine photographs
Child Labor Coalition
An overview of federal child labor laws
Curriculum ideas for teaching about child labor in the past and presen
OTHER TITLES OF INTEREST
Related Titles by Theme
Ashes of Roses
Mary Jane Auch
Historical Fiction: 20th Century • Hope
Death, Dying & Grief • Survival
Grades 7 up
The Broken Blade
Historical Fiction: 19th Century • Adventure
Family & Relationships • Survival
Grades 5 up
Yearling: 978-0-440-41184-0 (0-440-41184-X)
Mystery & Suspense • Humor • Ecology &
Conservation • Family & Relationships • Loyalty
Grades 5 up
Alfred A. Knopf PB:
Alfred A. Knopf HC:
GLB: 978-0-375-92182-7 (0-375-92182-6)
A House of Tailors
Patricia Reilly Giff
Family & Relationships • Historical Fiction:
19th Century • Growing Up
Yearling PB: 978-0-440-23800-3 (0-440-23800-5)
Wendy Lamb Books HC:
GLB: 978-0-385-90879-5 (0-385-90879-2)
Land of Hope
Joan Lowery Nixon
Historical Fiction: 20th Century • Jewish
Interest • Racism & Prejudice • Responsibility
Grades 5 up